Mithrandir Metrics
31 aligned 1 disagreements Refreshed Sep 26 06:00 AM ET
Section III · Betting · Consensus surface

Consensus and disagreement.

See where all three models converge and where their probabilities split.

Aligned
31
Soft
4
Disagreed
1
BANDS aligned ≤ 5pp · soft 6-10pp · disagreement > 10pp ELIGIBLE 1 markets MIXED 0 rows outside publish bands VIEW aligned
Strikeouts · Palantir calibration review Last 14d ECE 0.055, 14d stable. This flags probability calibration, not a blanket model failure.
Hits · Palantir calibration review Last 14d ECE 0.082, 14d error rising. This flags probability calibration, not a blanket model failure.
Lane Health 2026-09-26
Palantir 21711 props Brier 0.118 ECE 0.004 14d stable
Fangorn 21711 props Brier 0.118 ECE 0.005 14d stable
Valinor 16023 props Brier 0.114 ECE 0.001 14d stable
Palantir 1947 props Brier 0.248 ECE 0.011 14d stable
Fangorn 53 props Brier 0.257 ECE 0.119 sample building
Valinor 1443 props Brier 0.248 ECE 0.008 14d stable
Palantir 10429 props Brier 0.238 ECE 0.039 14d stable
Fangorn tracking in progress (0 logged)
Valinor tracking in progress (0 logged)
Palantir 850 props Brier 0.166 ECE 0.036 14d error rising
Fangorn tracking in progress (0 logged)
Valinor tracking in progress (0 logged)
Palantir 1088 props Brier 0.255 ECE 0.053 14d stable
Fangorn tracking in progress (0 logged)
Valinor tracking in progress (0 logged)
Palantir tracking in progress (0 logged)
Fangorn tracking in progress (0 logged)
Valinor tracking in progress (0 logged)
Filter rules Lineup filter defaults on. Rows hide players not confirmed in the lineup when lineup data is available. Positive gaps require context. Gaps below 2pp are treated as noise; 5pp is consensus, 6-10pp is soft consensus, and above 10pp is disagreement. Young players are labeled. Hitters under 50 MLB AB or pitchers under 20 MLB IP carry limited-sample context.
A · Three-lane aligned · spread ≤ 5pp
01 HR · 0.5 Vinnie Pasquantino KC vs CLE
P 17.0
F 15.6
V 17.4
FULL
FULL
16.7% average · market 17.7%
1.8 pts -1.0pp
02 HR · 0.5 Lawrence Butler ATH vs HOU
P 17.3
F 15.6
V 14.9
FULL
FULL
15.9% average · market 14.9%
2.4 pts +1.1pp
03 HR · 0.5 Corbin Carroll AZ vs SD
P 18.0
F 15.6
V 13.7
FULL
FULL
15.7% average · market 18.4%
4.3 pts -2.6pp
04 HR · 0.5 Ketel Marte AZ vs SD
P 16.4
F 15.6
V 14.4
FULL
FULL
15.5% average · market 21.1%
1.9 pts -5.6pp
05 HR · 0.5 Bobby Witt Jr. KC vs CLE
P 15.0
F 13.8
V 17.4
FULL
FULL
15.4% average · market 17.7%
3.6 pts -2.3pp
06 HR · 0.5 Brandon Nimmo TEX vs MIN
P 16.2
F 15.3
V 14.4
FULL
FULL
15.3% average · market 16.4%
1.7 pts -1.1pp
07 HR · 0.5 Shea Langeliers ATH vs HOU
P 16.1
F 14.4
V 15.3
FULL
FULL
15.3% average · market 20.8%
1.6 pts -5.6pp
08 HR · 0.5 Salvador Perez KC vs CLE
P 14.3
F 13.8
V 17.5
FULL
FULL
15.2% average · market 18.0%
3.8 pts -2.8pp
09 HR · 0.5 Iván Herrera STL vs MIL
P 15.7
F 15.3
V 14.0
FULL
FULL
15.0% average · market 12.5%
1.8 pts +2.5pp
10 HR · 0.5 Wyatt Langford TEX vs MIN
P 15.7
F 15.3
V 13.8
FULL
FULL
14.9% average · market 14.4%
1.9 pts +0.6pp
11 HR · 0.5 Corey Seager TEX vs MIN
P 14.0
F 14.4
V 15.2
FULL
FULL
14.5% average · market 22.5%
1.2 pts -7.9pp
12 HR · 0.5 Alec Burleson STL vs MIL
P 13.9
F 15.3
V 13.5
FULL
FULL
14.2% average · market 13.3%
1.7 pts +1.0pp
13 HR · 0.5 Heliot Ramos SF vs LAD
P 14.3
F 15.3
V 12.7
FULL
FULL
14.1% average · market 13.7%
2.5 pts +0.4pp
14 HR · 0.5 José Ramírez CLE vs KC
P 15.1
F 14.5
V 12.6
FULL
FULL
14.1% average · market 20.4%
2.6 pts -6.3pp
15 HR · 0.5 Hunter Goodman COL vs CWS
P 13.1
F 14.5
V 14.6
FULL
FULL
14.1% average · market 18.0%
1.5 pts -3.9pp
16 HR · 0.5 Brandon Lowe PIT vs DET
P 14.0
F 13.8
V 14.1
FULL
FULL
14.0% average · market 20.4%
0.4 pts -6.4pp
17 HR · 0.5 Evan Carter TEX vs MIN
P 15.4
F 15.3
V 11.2
FULL
FULL
14.0% average · market 11.0%
4.2 pts +3.0pp
18 HR · 0.5 Ryan O'Hearn PIT vs DET
P 12.7
F 14.5
V 14.0
FULL
FULL
13.8% average · market 13.0%
1.8 pts +0.8pp
19 HR · 0.5 Bryan Reynolds PIT vs DET
P 12.3
F 13.4
V 14.9
FULL
FULL
13.5% average · market 14.1%
2.6 pts -0.5pp
20 HR · 0.5 Geraldo Perdomo AZ vs SD
P 14.4
F 15.3
V 10.6
FULL
FULL
13.4% average · market 9.3%
4.6 pts +4.1pp
21 HR · 0.5 Josh Bell MIN vs TEX
P 13.1
F 13.8
V 12.9
FULL
FULL
13.3% average · market 15.5%
0.9 pts -2.2pp
22 HR · 0.5 Bo Naylor CLE vs KC
P 13.1
F 14.4
V 11.2
FULL
FULL
12.9% average · market 13.9%
3.2 pts -1.0pp
23 HR · 0.5 Jake Burger TEX vs MIN
P 9.8
F 13.3
V 14.2
FULL
FULL
12.4% average · market 19.2%
4.4 pts -6.8pp
24 HR · 0.5 Royce Lewis MIN vs TEX
P 9.3
F 13.3
V 14.0
FULL
FULL
12.2% average · market 15.8%
4.6 pts -3.5pp
25 HR · 0.5 Austin Hays CWS vs COL
P 12.2
F 13.8
V 10.3
FULL
FULL
12.1% average · market 11.7%
3.4 pts +0.4pp
26 HR · 0.5 Spencer Horwitz PIT vs DET
P 10.2
F 13.8
V 11.6
FULL
FULL
11.9% average · market 11.3%
3.6 pts +0.6pp
27 HR · 0.5 Brenton Doyle COL vs CWS
P 10.4
F 12.2
V 12.7
FULL
FULL
11.8% average · market 12.5%
2.4 pts -0.7pp
28 HR · 0.5 Ezequiel Tovar COL vs CWS
P 10.9
F 11.6
V 12.7
FULL
FULL
11.7% average · market 13.1%
1.8 pts -1.4pp
29 HR · 0.5 Andrew Benintendi CWS vs COL
P 10.6
F 13.8
V 10.1
FULL
FULL
11.5% average · market 12.2%
3.7 pts -0.7pp
30 HR · 0.5 Steven Kwan CLE vs KC
P 7.7
F 11.6
V 10.1
FULL
FULL
9.8% average · market 8.7%
3.9 pts +1.1pp
31 HR · 0.5 Daniel Schneemann CLE vs KC
P 10.5
F 8.9
V 9.3
FULL
FULL
9.6% average · market 11.1%
1.6 pts -1.5pp
B · Soft consensus · spread 6-10pp
C · Disagreement watch · spread > 10pp
D · Coverage transparency
Three-lane eligible 1 Home Runs
Partial coverage 0 No markets in this bucket today.
Single-lane 5 Strikeouts · Total Bases · Hits · Pitcher Outs · Futures
Contract 5 / 10 Consensus thresholds documented in the lane contract.